Last night’s debate may go down as one of the defining moments in presidential politics. Two smart guys. Different styles. Different views.
McCain is tough. I’d like him in my corner in a fight. However I wouldn’t want him choosing the fight to get into.
Obama’s style is diplomatic. I want him choosing the fight. He’s not going to back down. But he’s not going to start a war, except as a last resort.
As to who connected better with the audience last night, that goes to McCain. As to who addressed major challenges this country is faced with and offered solutions, Obama wins.
McCain really came to life when Iraq came up. What neither mentioned is that the surge is the first stage in the execution of a U.S. commitment to stay in Iraq for 50 years or longer. This commitment isn’t to Iraq. It’s to a policy that Bush hopes to make irreversible by knocking-up everybody’s darling David Petraeus from commander in Iraq to the central command of the Mideast. The Bush administration’s thinking is that the world strategic center of gravity has relocated from Europe to the Mideast. Petraeus wanted to command NATO but agreed to take the Mideast job.
McCain did say in so me words that our winning in Iraq is essential to our national security. That statement isn’t true just because McCain said it. What is true is that we have to stay there or Iraq will likely come under the control of the Shi’ite which is the predominant brand of Islam in Iran. Nobody in the Mideast wants to see a stronger Iran, which it would be if it controlled Iraq.
My view is that if the Mideast doesn’t want to see Iran go nuclear or to control Iraq, let the Mideast countries deal with it. We can’t even take care of our own business at home. We are killing our society with a commitment to conventional military solutions to unconventional strategies of our adversaries.
We continue to delude ourselves in thinking that we are the only world superpower. We’ve abdicated that financially. We’re not the only guys on the block with nukes. We are not the world hegemon.
McCain didn’t do any sword-rattling about attacking Iran, just imposition of sanctions by democratic powers. That won’t work. Expect to see China come in and take over Iran in the next few years.
Our interests in the region mostly have to do with oil. We are at or near world wide peak oil, so we either wean ourselves off the stuff immediately, or we are looking at a dystopian society very soon if the financial crash doesn’t get us there first.
On the peak oil deal, our only chance is to develop here in the US of A alternative sources of energy and very quickly. Tune in to the PBS Frontline two-hour episode “Heat” on October 21. If we follow through with Barack’s proposal to be energy independent in 10 years, the human species may survive if the remaining major energy users follow our lead.
On substantive issues, Obama wins at least 90 percent. Problem is, most people aren’t willing to face reality until there’s no more gasoline or the oceans start to boil.
I happen to be one of more than just a few who think that a severe economic setback is the best thing that could happen to this country. It would force us to get realistic about using militarism as our primary policy of international relations. It won’t work. We would come to realize that no higher power has imbued us with divine dispensation. It would provide us with the opportunity to come to know peace within ourselves.